My favorite part of this Cocotini is the combination of coconut rum, coconut cream, and lime juice in one chilled cocktail. A quick shake brings the creamy coconut and sharp citrus together.

The recipe makes 1 drink in about 5 minutes. Optional shredded coconut and a lime wedge finish the glass without adding another mixing step.

Prepare the glass before shaking so you can strain and serve straight away. This is an alcoholic cocktail for adults; the coconut flavor does not indicate its alcohol strength.

What Is a Cocotini?

This version is a coconut-rum drink served in a martini-style glass. It has a short ingredient list and a creamy texture, with lime juice to balance the coconut. The exact sweetness depends on the coconut rum and coconut cream you use.

Ingredients

• 2 ounces coconut rum
• 1 ounce coconut cream
• 1/2 ounce lime juice
• Ice
• Shredded coconut (optional, for garnish)
• Lime wedge (optional, for garnish)

Coconut Cream: Check the Label

The ingredient list calls for coconut cream. Stir it well before measuring because the fat and liquid can separate. Thai Kitchen’s coconut cream guidance explains this natural separation and recommends stirring before use.

Coconut cream and sweetened cream of coconut are different products. For example, GOYA cream of coconut contains added sugar. Swapping it in changes the sweetness; this recipe keeps the original coconut cream ingredient and amount.

Choosing and Measuring the Ingredients

Use a cocktail shaker to chill and combine the drink, a jigger for the small measurements, and a fine strainer if you prefer fewer ice chips. A small plate holds the optional coconut garnish.

Because this drink has only three measured ingredients, each one is easy to notice. Check the coconut rum label for both the product name and its alcohol percentage. Keep a note of the brand if you want to make the same version again. Changing brands can change the sweetness and coconut flavor even when the ounce measurements stay the same.

For the lime juice, squeeze into a small cup rather than straight into the shaker. Remove seeds and large pieces of pulp, then measure the juice. This also makes it easier to see whether you have enough before the other ingredients are mixed. A little pulp is a texture preference, but a seed should not end up in the finished glass.

Use ounce markings meant for liquids when measuring the rum, cream, and juice. Let thick coconut cream settle into the measure, then scrape it into the shaker with a small spoon. Cream clinging to the sides of the measure can leave you with less than the intended amount. Stirring the full container first makes each spoonful more consistent.

Fine shredded coconut makes a neater rim than long, coarse strands. If the pieces look too large, chop the portion you plan to use before putting it on the plate. Keep the rim narrow so the garnish stays around the lip instead of trailing down the glass. You can coat just half the rim, giving the person drinking it a choice of a coconut-covered or plain edge.

A small glass gives this short drink a balanced presentation. Choose one with a little room above the finished pour rather than filling right to the edge. The glass does not need to be large just because it is martini-shaped; the recipe is one measured cocktail, and a larger glass does not call for extra rum.

Kitchen Equipment You Will Need

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

• Cocktail shaker
• Jigger
• Fine strainer
• Small plate

How to Make a Cocotini

Step 1

Fill a martini glass or coupe with ice to chill it while you measure the ingredients. Stir the coconut cream until smooth before measuring 1 ounce; measure 2 ounces coconut rum and 1/2 ounce lime juice.

Step 2

Empty the chilling ice from the glass. If using the optional shredded coconut, lightly moisten the rim with a little of the measured coconut cream and press it into coconut on a small plate. Prepare the rim before filling the glass.

Step 3

Add the coconut rum, remaining measured coconut cream, and lime juice to a cocktail shaker. Stir briefly to loosen any thick coconut cream before adding the ice.

Step 4

Fill the shaker about two-thirds full with fresh ice, leaving room for it to move. Secure the lid and hold both parts firmly.

Step 5

Shake vigorously for about 15 seconds, until the shaker feels very cold and the ingredients are combined. Do not leave the drink sitting on the shaker ice after mixing.

Step 6

Strain into the prepared chilled glass, leaving the ice behind. If you want to catch tiny ice chips or coconut lumps, pour through a fine-mesh strainer as well.

Step 7

Add the optional lime wedge and serve immediately. This makes 1 cocktail and takes about 5 minutes, with no cooking step.

Tips for a Smooth Drink

Stir before measuring: Scooping only the solid top layer of a separated container can make the drink uneven. Mix the coconut cream together first, then measure the listed amount.

Measure the lime: The recipe uses 1/2 ounce, so measuring is more reliable than guessing from half a lime. Fruit sizes vary.

Use fresh ice: Discard the ice used to chill the glass and use fresh ice in the shaker. Shaking chills, dilutes, and combines the ingredients.

Rim first: Press the empty glass into the coconut before adding the cocktail. Trying to garnish a full glass makes spills much more likely.

Checking the Finished Texture

After shaking, the mixture should look combined and pour freely through the strainer. A light layer of tiny bubbles is normal for a shaken, creamy drink. It should not have a cap of firm whipped cream or the thickness of a frozen coconut dessert. Avoid blending it simply to make it look fuller; that would produce a different texture from this shaken version.

If coconut cream is sticking to the inside of the shaker, the problem is usually visible before you pour. Next time, spend a moment loosening the measured cream with the rum and lime before the ice goes in. This gives thick cream a chance to disperse instead of leaving a dense patch at the bottom that shaking has to break apart.

If you double the recipe for two servings, set both glasses beside the shaker and divide the doubled batch between them rather than filling one to the brim first. This helps keep the portions even. If you use separate batches, repeat the same measurements and shaking method for each. Consistent preparation matters more than making the optional garnish look elaborate.

A fine strainer can slow the pour when cream collects in the mesh. Pour steadily and give the liquid time to pass through. Do not force large pieces through just to empty the strainer faster. Put the lime wedge on last, leaving the drinking edge easy to reach.

Serving Ideas

Serve the Cocotini as a small cocktail alongside Air Fryer Shrimp, or pair it with a dinner of Coconut Lime Chicken. Offer Cracker Barrel Peach Tea as a separate alcohol-free drink option for guests who prefer one.

Make Ahead and Storage

For the best texture, measure and shake each drink close to serving. Have the glass and optional garnish ready first. If making several drinks, keep the same ratio and shake in small batches so there is enough room for ice to move.

Refrigerate opened coconut cream as directed on its label and use it within the manufacturer’s stated period. Keep garnishes covered and chilled until needed. This recipe has no validated storage period for a premixed cocktail, so avoid keeping a finished batch for later service.

FAQ

Is coconut milk the same as coconut cream?

No. Coconut milk is generally thinner. Using it changes the texture, so keep coconut cream for this version rather than swapping it in without adjusting the recipe.

Why are there small white flecks?

Cold coconut fat can form small pieces. Stir the coconut cream thoroughly before measuring, loosen it with the other ingredients before adding ice, and fine-strain the shaken drink if needed.

Can I double the recipe?

Double all three measured ingredients for 2 cocktails and divide between 2 prepared glasses. If the shaker is crowded once ice is added, shake separate batches.

Can I use an ordinary glass?

Yes. A small chilled stemless glass works if you do not have a martini glass or coupe. Strain out the shaker ice and serve the drink right away.

How strong is this cocktail?

It depends on the alcohol percentage of the coconut rum and the dilution from shaking. Check the bottle label rather than assuming every brand has the same strength. No fixed alcohol-by-volume claim is made for this recipe.