My favorite part of a fish dinner is often the little bowl of tartar sauce beside it. This Cracker Barrel-inspired version is creamy and tangy, with finely chopped dill pickles, onion, lemon juice, and a touch of sugar. It is an easy homemade copycat, not an official restaurant formula.

Tartar sauce is already a favorite on this blog, with Luby’s tartar sauce and Captain D’s tartar sauce offering other versions to explore. This one keeps the preparation simple and lets the pickle flavor come through the mayonnaise.

You need about 10 minutes to chop and stir, then at least an hour in the refrigerator. That rest gives the onion and dill time to flavor the creamy base. Serve it cold with fish, seafood, sandwiches, or crisp vegetables, and keep the rest of the batch chilled until needed.

Why This Tartar Sauce Is Great

• Everything mixes in one bowl, and there is no cooking or hot pan to manage.
• Finely chopped dill pickles give little bites of crunch throughout the creamy sauce.
• Lemon juice adds brightness that pairs well with fried fish and rich seafood dishes.
• A small amount of sugar softens the sharp pickle and lemon flavors without making it a sweet dip.
• The sauce can be prepared before the rest of the meal, leaving your hands free when the fish is ready.
• The same batch works as a dip, a sandwich spread, or a cool spoonful alongside grilled fish.

What Is the Best Mayonnaise for Tartar Sauce?

Choose a ready-made mayonnaise you enjoy eating on its own, since it forms most of the sauce. A thick, plain mayonnaise gives a creamy base that holds the chopped pickles in place. Strongly sweet or heavily flavored spreads will change the balance before you add the lemon, sugar, and seasonings.

Start with chilled mayonnaise and check the package storage directions. A light mayonnaise can work, but different brands vary in thickness and tanginess. There is no need to make raw-egg mayonnaise for this recipe. If you are cooking for someone with an allergy, check the mayonnaise and pickle labels rather than assuming every brand has the same ingredients.

Ingredients

• 1 cup mayonnaise
• 2 tablespoons finely chopped dill pickles
• 1 tablespoon finely chopped onion
• 1 tablespoon lemon juice
• 1 teaspoon sugar
• 1/2 teaspoon salt
• 1/4 teaspoon black pepper
• 1/4 teaspoon dried dill (optional)

Drain the pickles before measuring the chopped pieces. Extra pickle liquid can thin the sauce and make it noticeably saltier. Use a mild onion and mince it finely so the flavor spreads through the mayonnaise instead of landing in large, sharp bites. The dried dill is optional, while the listed salt and sugar belong to the original base recipe.

Kitchen Equipment You Will Need

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

• Chef’s knife
• Cutting board
• Measuring cups
• Measuring spoons
• Medium mixing bowl with lid
• Mixing spoon
• Paper towels
• Airtight storage container
• Serving bowl
• Serving spoon

How To Make Cracker Barrel Tartar Sauce

Step 1

Drain the dill pickles and blot away extra brine with a paper towel. Finely chop and measure 2 tablespoons of pickles and 1 tablespoon of onion. Combine them with 1 cup mayonnaise in a medium mixing bowl.

Step 2

Add 1 tablespoon lemon juice, 1 teaspoon sugar, 1/2 teaspoon salt, and 1/4 teaspoon black pepper. Add 1/4 teaspoon dried dill if using.

Step 3

Stir thoroughly, scraping the sides and bottom of the bowl, until the seasonings are evenly mixed and the pickle and onion pieces are distributed throughout the mayonnaise. The sauce should be creamy and spoonable, with small pieces rather than large chunks.

Step 4

Cover the bowl and refrigerate at 40°F or below for at least 1 hour to let the flavors blend. Keep it refrigerated until the rest of the meal is ready. The total preparation and chilling time is at least 1 hour 10 minutes.

Step 5

Stir again and serve chilled in a clean serving bowl with a separate spoon. Keep the remaining sauce covered in the refrigerator and use within 3–4 days. Discard sauce left out for more than 2 hours, or more than 1 hour when the temperature is above 90°F.

The yield is listed as one batch because the recipe starts with a full cup of mayonnaise and then adds pickles, onion, lemon juice, and seasonings. The finished amount is therefore more than one cup, with the exact volume depending on the ingredients and how finely they are chopped. Choose a container with a little extra room for stirring.

Notes

• Chop the pickles by hand into tiny pieces. This keeps their crunch while making the sauce easy to spread on a sandwich.
• Measure the chopped onion after cutting it. A large spoonful of uneven pieces can make the sauce taste more onion-heavy than intended.
• Drain and blot the pickles before they enter the bowl. It is easier to keep extra brine out than to thicken a watery sauce later.
• Keep the lemon juice measured. Pouring it straight from a bottle can quickly loosen the mayonnaise more than you expect.
• Allow the full hour of chilling before judging the flavor. The dried dill softens and the onion becomes more evenly distributed during the rest.
• The original recipe includes 1/2 teaspoon salt, and mayonnaise and pickles already contain sodium. Avoid adding extra salt without tasting the chilled sauce with the food you will serve.
• Use clean utensils for the sauce and keep them separate from raw fish preparation. Never return sauce from a used plate to the storage container.

Ingredients You Can Add

These optional ideas make a different version of the sauce. Try one in a small serving first so you can decide whether you like it before changing the entire bowl.

• Fresh parsley gives a mild, leafy flavor and a little color without covering up the pickles.
• Chopped chives add a gentler onion note that works especially well with fish sandwiches.
• Finely chopped capers bring a briny flavor. Drain them well and remember that they add saltiness too.
• A little Dijon mustard gives a sharper, savory edge. It also changes the color slightly.
• Prepared horseradish adds a peppery bite that can stand up to fried seafood and rich fish cakes.
• A small pinch of cayenne adds warmth without extra liquid. Start lightly because it becomes more noticeable through the creamy base.

What To Serve with Tartar Sauce

Fish and chips are a classic pairing, and salmon cakes are another lovely choice. Serve the sauce in a small bowl on the side so each person can add what they like without softening the crisp surface of the fish.

Spread a thin layer on a fish sandwich just before eating, or use it as a dip for cooked shrimp, calamari, and other seafood appetizers. A separate serving spoon keeps crumbs out of the sauce. If you are serving several dishes, refill a small bowl from the chilled batch instead of putting all of it on the table.

For a simple vegetable option, offer it with carrot sticks, celery, or bell pepper strips. It also makes a tangy topping for a baked potato or a cool accompaniment to grilled fish. The sauce is already rich and seasoned, so start with a small amount and add more only if needed.

Variations and Swaps

• Dill relish version: use well-drained dill relish in place of the chopped pickles for finer pieces and a slightly different texture.
• Sweet pickle version: sweet pickles give a noticeably sweeter result. Treat this as a different flavor rather than an exact match to the base sauce.
• Fresh dill version: replace the optional dried dill with finely chopped fresh dill to taste for a brighter herbal finish.
• Lime variation: lime juice can replace the lemon juice for a different citrus note while keeping the measured liquid amount the same.
• Yogurt variation: replacing some mayonnaise with thick plain Greek yogurt gives a tangier, less rich sauce. Its texture and flavor will be different.
• Onion variation: finely chopped shallot can replace the onion when you prefer its flavor. Keep the pieces small and measure after chopping.
• Spicy variation: finely chopped jalapeño adds a fresh pepper flavor and heat. Handle it carefully and avoid touching your eyes.
• Lower-sodium ingredients: compare mayonnaise and pickle labels when choosing ingredients. Their sodium levels vary, even before the recipe’s measured salt is added.

Storage

Store the sauce in a clean, airtight container in the refrigerator at 40°F or below and use within 3–4 days. Label the container with the day it was made, and follow an earlier use-by limit if any ingredient requires one. Stir before serving, and use a clean spoon each time to keep crumbs and other food out.

Discard sauce that has been out for more than 2 hours, or more than 1 hour above 90°F. Lemon juice and pickles do not make this homemade mixture shelf-stable. Freezing is not recommended for the best texture because mayonnaise can separate and the vegetables can release water after thawing. Making a fresh batch is usually simpler than trying to repair a separated one.

FAQ

Is this the official Cracker Barrel recipe?

No. It is a homemade copycat inspired by a creamy, tangy tartar sauce. Restaurant recipes and ingredients can differ, so this version does not promise an exact match or claim access to the restaurant’s formula.

Why is my tartar sauce runny?

Wet pickles, extra lemon juice, or a thinner mayonnaise can loosen the mixture. Drain the pickles, measure the lemon, and chill before judging it. If it remains loose, use it as a drizzle rather than adding unmeasured ingredients to the whole batch.

Can I skip the chilling time?

The ingredients are ready to eat once mixed, but the one-hour refrigerator rest is part of this recipe’s method. It gives the onion, dill, and seasonings time to blend into the mayonnaise and makes the finished flavor more even.

Can I make it ahead for dinner?

Yes. Mix it earlier in the day, cover it, and refrigerate until serving. Give it a quick stir before transferring a small amount to the table. The rest of the batch should remain cold.

Is the sauce gluten-free?

That depends on the ingredients you choose. Check the mayonnaise, pickles, and seasonings for gluten-containing ingredients and relevant labeling. Keep preparation utensils clean if avoiding cross-contact is important; the recipe name alone is not a guarantee.

Can I leave out the dried dill?

Yes. The dried dill is already marked optional, and the dill pickles still provide an herbal pickle flavor. Omitting it keeps the sauce simpler without changing the measured mayonnaise, lemon juice, onion, or seasonings.

Short Description

A homemade Cracker Barrel-inspired tartar sauce with mayonnaise, dill pickles, onion, lemon, and simple seasonings. Chill for at least 1 hour before serving with fish or seafood.