Spider Cookies Recipe
I love these Spider Cookies for their crunchy legs and wide candy eyes. I discovered them at my son’s preschool party, where parents were asking for the recipe. A few familiar snacks become a little Halloween character with some simple assembly.
I use creamy peanut butter and regular chocolate sandwich cookies. Smooth filling is easier to spread, while the standard cookies keep each spider from becoming too tall. Have the pretzel legs and eyes ready before you start building.
This batch makes 24 spiders using two whole sandwich cookies for each body. Allow about an hour, including a short chill. Children can help with suitable decorations under supervision; an adult should handle the microwave and hot chocolate.

Why This Dish Is Great
- No baking: Ready-made cookies form the bodies. The only heating is a brief microwave melt for the chocolate used to attach the eyes.
- A useful assembly line: Set out cookies, filling, legs, and eyes in order. Working on a few spiders at a time keeps the tray manageable.
- Sweet and salty: Chocolate cookies and peanut butter make a rich center, while pretzel legs add a crisp, lightly salty bite.
- Easy personalities: Move the eyes closer together or angle the legs slightly. Small differences make each spider look playful without difficult piping.
- Party portions: The ingredient counts divide evenly into 24 substantial treats. A single layer on a tray gives their fragile legs plenty of room.
Choosing Cookies And Peanut Butter
Choose flat, round chocolate sandwich cookies with their filling intact. Each spider uses two complete cookies with an extra peanut butter layer between them. Do not twist them apart: keeping them whole makes the 48-cookie ingredient amount fit the 24-spider batch.
Use creamy peanut butter at a spreadable room temperature. Stir any separated oil back into the jar before measuring. Very runny peanut butter makes weaker joints for the legs, while a cold, stiff spread can break the cookies when you press. Read the labels before serving to guests with allergies.
Ingredients
For the Spiders
- 48 round chocolate sandwich cookies (like Oreos)
- 1 cup creamy peanut butter
- 1/2 cup powdered sugar
- 96 pretzel sticks (for legs)
- 48 candy eyes
- 1/2 cup chocolate chips (for attaching eyes)
Alternative Decorations
- Red candy melts (for black widow markings)
- White chocolate chips (for different eye colors)
- Mini chocolate chips (for smaller eyes)
The 1 cup peanut butter and 1/2 cup powdered sugar form the filling for all 24 bodies. Break each of the 96 pretzel sticks in half for 192 legs, eight per spider. Use two of the 48 candy eyes per spider. The red melts, white chips, and mini chips are optional decorations.
Kitchen Equipment You Will Need
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- Mixing bowl
- Silicone spatula
- Measuring cups
- Offset spatula
- Baking sheets
- Parchment paper
- Microwave-safe bowls
- Teaspoon
- Serving platter
- Serving tongs
- Kitchen scissors
- Airtight containers

How To Make Spider Cookies
Allow about 60 minutes: 45 minutes for breaking pretzels, mixing, assembling, melting, and decorating, plus 15 minutes chilling after the last spider is finished. There is no baking. Elaborate markings or several coating colors take extra time; let the chocolate become firm before moving the cookies.
Step 1
Line two baking sheets with parchment. Keep all 48 sandwich cookies intact and arrange 24 as bases, reserving the other 24 as tops. Break all 96 pretzel sticks in half to make 192 legs. Set out the 48 candy eyes in a clean bowl.
Step 2
Stir the full 1 cup creamy peanut butter and 1/2 cup powdered sugar together until smooth. Scrape the bowl so no dry sugar remains. The filling should hold a soft mound; if it is unusually loose, chill it briefly until spreadable rather than adding extra ingredients.
Step 3
Divide the filling evenly over the 24 base cookies, spreading it nearly to the edges. Keep the reserved top cookies nearby. Work on a few bases at a time so you can fit the legs before closing each body.
Step 4
Place eight half-pretzel pieces into each filling layer, four on the left and four on the right. Lay them flat enough to be held by the filling, leaving their outer ends visible. Gently add one reserved whole sandwich cookie on top of each base. Avoid squeezing the filling out.
Step 5
Put all 1/2 cup chocolate chips into a dry microwave-safe bowl. An adult should microwave them in short intervals at reduced power, stirring each time, until just melted. Allow roughly 2–3 minutes including stirring, depending on the microwave. The bowl and chocolate may be hot.
Step 6
Use a teaspoon to place small chocolate dots on top of each spider. Attach two candy eyes to every body, using all 48. Drizzle any remaining melted chocolate thinly over the backs. Keep the eyes visible.
Step 7
For optional markings, melt red candy melts according to their package and add a small hourglass on the back. Optional white chocolate chips can make pale dots, with mini chocolate chips as pupils. Use only edible decorations and let hot coating cool to a comfortable working temperature.
Step 8
Refrigerate the trays for about 15 minutes after decorating, until the chocolate is firm. Keep the spiders in one layer so no legs are crushed. If your trays do not fit at once, chill them in batches and allow additional time.
Step 9
If desired, melt the optional white chocolate chips and drizzle a web onto a clean serving platter. Let it set before arranging the spiders. Keep plastic props away from the food and use edible cookie pieces for any graveyard scene.
Step 10
Lift each spider by its cookie body, never by a leg. Serve when the filling is comfortably soft, or keep the fully set cookies in a single layer in an airtight container. Follow the storage directions on any substituted filling or decoration.
Notes
- Count first: Make 24 groups of eight pretzel pieces before spreading the filling. This avoids reaching the last spider without enough matching legs.
- Spread gently: Support the cookie on the tray and use a small spatula. Heavy pressure can crack the base before its top is attached.
- Set the legs before closing: Pressing pretzels into an already closed stack can push the filling out or break the leg ends.
- Keep tools dry: Water can make melted chocolate thick and grainy. Dry the bowl and spoon before adding the chips.
- Use small eye dots: Too much wet chocolate lets eyes slide. A tiny dab holds them more neatly while the rest becomes a thin drizzle.
- Move by the body: Pretzels make fragile handles. Slide a spatula underneath when transferring finished spiders to their serving platter.
- Plan for guests: Check school food rules and ingredient labels. Hard candy eyes and pretzel pieces may be unsuitable for very young children.
Ingredients You Can Add
- Colored candy melts: Drizzle a little across the backs for bright markings. Melt each color separately according to its package directions.
- Edible glitter: Sprinkle onto wet chocolate only if the product is labeled edible and lists ingredients. Decorative-only dust is unsuitable.
- Licorice strings: Cut short edible strands for a different leg shape. Keep long dangling strings off a tray intended for small children.
- Coconut flakes: Scatter over wet chocolate to give the bodies a fuzzy look. Leave space around the candy eyes.
- Food markers: Use markers specifically sold for edible decorating to add details to set pale candy coating. Craft markers are unsuitable.
- Almond butter: It gives a different nut flavor in the filling. It contains tree nuts and is not a general allergy-safe replacement.
What To Serve
One of my favorite presentations is a cookie graveyard with edible graham-cracker tombstones and a chocolate web on the platter. Add Spooky Mummy Brownies on a separate tray for another Halloween character without crowding the spider legs.
For a mix of chewy and crunchy treats, serve Monster Rice Krispie Treats beside the spiders. Milk or a warm drink works well with both. Set serving tongs beside each platter so guests can lift treats without touching the others.
If the party includes dinner, Jack O’Lantern Stuffed Peppers keep the Halloween theme going before dessert. Bring out a small cookie tray at a time and refill it gently, leaving space for guests to pick up each body.
Recipe Variations And Swaps
- Peanut-free filling: Sunflower butter or suitable chocolate frosting can replace peanut butter. Check all labels and cross-contact warnings; a swap alone does not make the whole tray allergy-safe.
- Pale spiders: Use vanilla sandwich cookies and white chocolate for a lighter look. Edible black decorating gel can add small face details.
- Gluten-free spiders: Choose labeled gluten-free cookies and pretzels, then check the eyes, chocolate, and filling. Texture and fragility can differ by brand.
- Mini spider bites: Use mini sandwich cookies and short pretzel pieces. The suggested yield of about 48 mini spiders needs 96 mini cookies, with eyes and legs scaled to the number assembled.
- Colorful spiders: Coat the top cookies with colored candy melts before assembly and let them set. Coating a finished spider risks pulling its delicate legs loose.
- Large tarantulas: Larger round snack cakes can form bigger bodies with longer pretzel pieces. This changes the yield and filling needs, so plan the tray separately.
- Oat-cookie spiders: Use ready-to-eat oat cookies with date filling for a different flavor. Check the filling’s storage instructions rather than assuming the base recipe’s room-temperature storage applies.
- Ice cream spiders: Use ice cream between cookies for a frozen variation. Assemble cold, freeze promptly, and serve immediately from the freezer; do not leave these on a room-temperature buffet.

How To Store
Store the base peanut-butter version in a single layer in an airtight container at cool room temperature for up to 3 days for best texture, or less if a product label requires it. Keep away from sunlight and heat. A short setting chill is useful, but long refrigeration can soften cookies and pretzels.
For longer storage, freeze in a single layer until firm, then pack carefully in a rigid airtight freezer container for up to 1 month. Thaw covered at room temperature, allowing about 30 minutes or until the filling softens; pretzels may lose some crunch. Any cream-cheese or other perishable filling needs refrigerator storage and its own shorter limits.
FAQ
Why are my legs falling out?
The filling may be too soft, or the legs may be sitting only at its edge. Chill the filling briefly and place the pretzel ends well inside before adding the top cookie.
Do I split the sandwich cookies?
No. Use two whole sandwich cookies per spider. The peanut butter layer between them holds the legs, and all 48 cookies make the stated 24 spiders.
Can I skip peanut butter?
Use a suitable sunflower butter or thick chocolate frosting if it meets your guests’ needs. Check every ingredient, and follow the substitute’s storage directions.
Why will the eyes not stick?
Use a fresh dot of melted chocolate and press each eye lightly while it is still wet. Let it set before moving the tray.
Can children decorate these?
Yes, with age-appropriate supervision and suitable candies. Adults should handle the microwave and hot bowls. Small hard pieces are unsuitable for some young children.
How should I transport them?
Use a shallow, rigid container in one layer. Keep it flat and cool, and carry spare pretzel pieces for replacing any legs broken in transit.
Short Description
Spider Cookies pair chocolate sandwich cookies with creamy peanut butter filling, crunchy pretzel legs, and candy eyes. These Halloween treats need no baking, with a short chill to set the chocolate decorations.
Spider Cookies Recipe
Course: DessertCuisine: AmericanDifficulty: Easy24
spider cookies45
minutes1
hourSpider Cookies pair chocolate sandwich cookies with creamy peanut butter filling, crunchy pretzel legs, and candy eyes. These Halloween treats need no baking, with a short chill to set the chocolate decorations.
Ingredients
- For the Spiders:
48 round chocolate sandwich cookies (like Oreos)
1 cup creamy peanut butter
1/2 cup powdered sugar
96 pretzel sticks (for legs)
48 candy eyes
1/2 cup chocolate chips (for attaching eyes)
- Alternative Decorations:
Red candy melts (for black widow markings)
White chocolate chips (for different eye colors)
Mini chocolate chips (for smaller eyes)
Directions
- Line two baking sheets with parchment. Keep all 48 sandwich cookies intact and arrange 24 as bases, reserving the other 24 as tops. Break all 96 pretzel sticks in half to make 192 legs. Set out the 48 candy eyes in a clean bowl.
- Stir the full 1 cup creamy peanut butter and 1/2 cup powdered sugar together until smooth. Scrape the bowl so no dry sugar remains. The filling should hold a soft mound; if it is unusually loose, chill it briefly until spreadable rather than adding extra ingredients.
- Divide the filling evenly over the 24 base cookies, spreading it nearly to the edges. Keep the reserved top cookies nearby. Work on a few bases at a time so you can fit the legs before closing each body.
- Place eight half-pretzel pieces into each filling layer, four on the left and four on the right. Lay them flat enough to be held by the filling, leaving their outer ends visible. Gently add one reserved whole sandwich cookie on top of each base. Avoid squeezing the filling out.
- Put all 1/2 cup chocolate chips into a dry microwave-safe bowl. An adult should microwave them in short intervals at reduced power, stirring each time, until just melted. Allow roughly 2–3 minutes including stirring, depending on the microwave. The bowl and chocolate may be hot.
- Use a teaspoon to place small chocolate dots on top of each spider. Attach two candy eyes to every body, using all 48. Drizzle any remaining melted chocolate thinly over the backs. Keep the eyes visible.
- For optional markings, melt red candy melts according to their package and add a small hourglass on the back. Optional white chocolate chips can make pale dots, with mini chocolate chips as pupils. Use only edible decorations and let hot coating cool to a comfortable working temperature.
- Refrigerate the trays for about 15 minutes after decorating, until the chocolate is firm. Keep the spiders in one layer so no legs are crushed. If your trays do not fit at once, chill them in batches and allow additional time.
- If desired, melt the optional white chocolate chips and drizzle a web onto a clean serving platter. Let it set before arranging the spiders. Keep plastic props away from the food and use edible cookie pieces for any graveyard scene.
- Lift each spider by its cookie body, never by a leg. Serve when the filling is comfortably soft, or keep the fully set cookies in a single layer in an airtight container. Follow the storage directions on any substituted filling or decoration.
Notes
- Makes 24 spiders from 48 intact sandwich cookies, paired two per spider. Do not split the cookies into halves. Divide all peanut butter filling between the 24 pairs.
- Break 96 pretzel sticks in half for 192 legs: eight per spider. Use two candy eyes per spider, all 48. Use the measured 1/2 cup chocolate chips for eye dots and thin back drizzles.
- Allow 45 minutes active preparation, including brief chocolate melting, plus 15 minutes chilling for 60 minutes total. There is no baking; additional tray batches or elaborate optional decorations add time.
- Peanut butter contains peanuts; almond butter is not a nut-free substitute. Check every ingredient and cross-contact information for any allergy-sensitive version. Adults handle hot melted chocolate.
- Store the base version airtight at cool room temperature for up to 3 days for best crunch, following any shorter label directions. Perishable fillings need refrigeration. Keep fragile legs in a single layer.
